The “Beckenbauer of the East,” a traitor the Stasi never forgave

“The evidence suggests that she then fell prey to Mielke’s [the head of the Stasi] apparatus, who wanted revenge and to make a difference three days before a friendly match between FC Dynamo Berlin and Stuttgart,” explains historian Jens Gieseke in his book on the history of the Stasi ( Die Stasi: 1945–1990 , 2011). “Don’t forget Eigendorf,” is what people often hear in the corridors of the German intelligence service’s offices.

Elegant. Subtle. With unquestionable technical ability and extraordinary intelligence on the pitch. The midfielder for Dynamo Berlin, the favorite team of the communist GDR regime, was considered one of the great promises of his country's football. A different kind of player who represented the success of East German sport, an emblem and propaganda tool in the mirror game that placed him opposite Franz Beckenbauer, the great star of the other Germany, the one that had surrendered to capitalism beyond the Wall.

“The GDR always tried to be an exemplary student of the Olympic movement, knowing that it was there that it achieved its greatest successes. Since Mexico City in 1968, it had managed to surpass West Germany in the medal table at every Olympic Games. With this, the GDR wanted to demonstrate that it was also the 'best Germany' politically. In 1976, the small country even beat the United States, and in 1984, in Sarajevo, it even surpassed its 'Big Brother,' the Soviet Union,” explains Jutta Braun, a historian at the ZZF Potsdam, an institute dedicated to contemporary German and European history.

When he decided to escape, the betrayal was not only political but also symbolic. His escape represented the shattering of a myth, the denial of an ideal honed for years by the regime. And, above all, the profound disappointment of Erich Mielke, head of the Stasi and president of Dynamo Berlin, for whom Lutz was more than just a player.

“At first, their relationship had paternal overtones. Mielke adopted Lutz as his protégé, believing he could contribute greatly to the team and the country. He granted him favors beyond those usual for a promising player and treated him like a son,” says writer and journalist Eduardo Verdú, who made Eigendorf the protagonist of his novel Todo lo que ganamos cuando lo perdido todo (All We Gained When We Lost Everything , Plaza & Janés, 2018).

But in the GDR, every privilege came at a price. Mielke's confidence was tied to the condemnation of his loss of freedom. His life was measured, monitored, and controlled. "Over time, Lutz began to see the corruption in football and in the regime, which deeply disappointed him. He felt politically exploited, pushed to the extreme in the national team, burdened with the responsibility of representing an entire country. The pressure was disproportionate, and the reality of match-fixing in football made him realize that Mielke was not the man of integrity he appeared to be," the journalist continues.

Mielke, the shadowy head of the GDR's political police and Erich Honecker's right-hand man, was a fanatic of the beautiful game with a secret obsession: to make his Dynamo Berlin the biggest club in Germany. Threats of jail, bribery, or match-fixing were all he could do to make his team the "Bayern Munich of East Germany." He even deprived the country's main rival, Dynamo Dresden, of all its talent and power.

In 1954, Mielke brought the best players, including coaches, from the then league champions to Berlin by decree. “Sports in the GDR served as a showcase for socialism, and athletes were considered 'diplomats in tracksuits.' In the ideology of the Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED), the level of sport was similar to that of the military. GDR athletes were not only expected to defeat West Germany's 'class enemies' in athletics, but also to 'hate' them as political adversaries,” Braun explains.

The same can be applied to football. The top league, the DDR-Oberliga, operated from 1949 until German reunification in 1990 as a tool of propaganda and social control. The flight of any athlete was a particularly embarrassing event for the regime, as it meant that a socialist idol had switched sides and achieved success in the opposing political camp.

One of the hardest blows to the government was the escape of long-distance swimmer Axel Mitbauer, who swam more than 20 kilometers across the Baltic Sea to Lübeck in 1969. In response, the Stasi intensified surveillance of elite athletes.

Lutz Eigendorf was one of the estimated 500 athletes who fled the GDR in the late 1970s. And while all were persecuted, few suffered such systematic and prolonged harassment as the Dynamo Berlin star had to endure.

East Germany is considered one of the most sophisticated spy states of all time. And the Stasi was its insatiable tentacle, the apparatus that monitored a country of 17 million people, with a permanent staff of more than 97,000 agents (1.5 times that of the GDR army) and a dense network of more than 173,000 informants.

According to historian John Koehler, Mielke transformed the Stasi into "an instrument of oppression for the East German population, as well as one of the most effective intelligence services in the world." It is estimated that the German intelligence agency deployed more than fifty agents to monitor and document every step Lutz Eigendorf took in his new life.

Read also Nadia Comaneci, the captive fairy Eduardo Mesa Leiva

After defecting in 1979, the footballer settled in West Germany, where he sought to continue his football career. “His escape wasn't just to improve as a footballer, but to escape a rigged competition. He also wanted to compete against the best players in the world and leave behind the closed environment he found himself in,” says Verdú.

“Furthermore,” the Madrid-based journalist continues, “he was seduced by the prospect of becoming a star in a capitalist world, with its privileges and opportunities. He dreamed of enjoying the luxuries and advantages that the other side of the Wall offered: fame, money, cars, women, and the attention of the press. He sought not only a more brilliant athletic career, but a fuller, freer life.”

Lutz Eigendorf's wife, Gabrielle, suffered a complicated fate after her husband deserted her. The Stasi intervened in her personal life to such an extent that they sent a secret service agent to seduce her, convince her to divorce her husband, remarry, and have another child.

Accident or murder?

For his part, Eigendorf also tried to rebuild his life in West Germany and start a new family. On the sporting front, after playing for FC Kaiserlautern for two years (1980-1982), he played his last matches with Eintrach Braunschweig. And although his life seemed to finally be on the mend, he was never able to escape the invisible shadow of the Stasi.

On that curve in Querum, Lutz's life went off the rails. He had managed to flee a country, but not his destiny. Football had been his passion, his escape, but not even sport could protect him from the relentless grasp of those who never stopped seeing him as a traitor. Until that fateful night in March.

Accident or murder? “In my novel, I speculate on the idea of ​​a hitman and various methods, such as the use of poison, but the truth is difficult to establish. What we do know is that there was an intense pursuit and that they undoubtedly wanted him dead. The details may be shrouded in mystery, but the Stasi's objective leaves no room for doubt,” says Eduardo Verdú.

Read also From ballet to hockey: the weapons of Soviet soft power Eduardo Mesa Leiva

The death of the “Beckenbauer of the East” was also a warning: the punishment announced for all those who ever dared to dream of crossing the red line and imagining a life beyond the Wall. “Was Eigendorf merely a vicarious satisfaction of the desire for revenge against the 'traitors' of a new, ungrateful generation seeking salvation in the shining West?” Jens Gieseke asks.